Word Detective tells us something interesting that we hadn't considered. When we think of "sick as a dog" we need to keep in mind what that meant back in 18th century Europe.
Back then, to "be sick" didn't mean to feel unwell, it referred to tummy troubles. Specifically the kind where you vomit.
photo: Creative Commons 3.0 |
And since dogs historically have a bit of a reputation in this department (well, they will eat almost anything, we've heard...!) the reference kinda makes sense.
As the phrase moved through the centuries, sometimes other animals were dragged into the mix, including cats, rats and even horses. (Which is interesting, actually, since we learned horses cannot vomit!)
Though the weirdest version goes - paws down - to the one Jonathan Swift used in his book Polite Conversations, written in 1738: "Poor Miss, she's sick as a cushion, she wants nothing but stuffing."
Um...huh? Or, as one of the peeps our mom works with says, "Whatevs!"
________
sources: All Experts, Word Detective and Worldwide Words
Sick as a cushion!!!! LOL! Have a terrific Thursday.
ReplyDeleteBest wishes Molly
How on earth does a cushion get sick? Hmmmm.
ReplyDeleteSome of those expressions have been around forever and you wonder how they got started. Now we know where "Sick as a dog" came from.
ReplyDeleteWhat could a cushion possibly eat that would make it sick? HOW could a cushion eat? MOL!
ReplyDeleteThanks for such an interesting post, dear pals.
Hugs to you all!
MOL cushion.. Probably ate too much stuffing.. xx00xx
ReplyDeleteMollie and Alfie
Bwaaa-ha-haaaa! Good one!
DeletePe-ess Or was stuffed to the brim, so was sick..Mol xx00xx
ReplyDeleteMollie and Alfie
Very interesting. We didn't know the origin of the phrase; however; Mom says that it should be "Sick as a cat." 'cause the dogs the humans used to have never threw up as much as we do. We like the cute doggy picture. Purrs and hugs from the kitties at www.thecatonmyhead.com, Lily Olivia, Mauricio, Misty May, Giulietta, Fiona, Astrid, Lisbeth and Calista Josette
ReplyDeleteMOL - Ryker was MASTER of that. mommy used to say he would Feng (err, FANG) Shui them, he had so many - up to 9 a day! He had IBD.
DeleteSick as a cushion? That's funny! Our mum says sick as a pig.
ReplyDeleteThis was me on Monday and Tuesday...I was definitely "sick as a cushion" and stuffing would have been a welcome event...Fun post!
ReplyDeleteOh my CAT, Giz! Are you better? That is NOT good. Not good at all!!
DeleteSick as a cushion!! That is not good!
ReplyDeleteSeriously? We didn't know that!
ReplyDeleteVery interesting. I have always used sick in the eighteenth century meaning.
ReplyDeleteBetter dogs than cats, MOL!
ReplyDeleteWell that's interesting!! I've had the odd cushion that has looked quite sick when its been sat on too long!! We usually say "sick as a dog" when we've had too much to drink and are kissing the lino! ;)
ReplyDeleteSick as a cushion??? That guy clearly needs medical help. ; )
ReplyDeleteAnd I've NEVER heard "sick as a cat."
I say let's just stick with dogs on this.
; ) Katie
Excellent blog! I found it while surfing around on Google. Content of this page is unique as well as well researched. Appreciate it. www.k9nerds.com/why-do-dogs-dig-in-their-beds
ReplyDelete